Understanding Investing Risk and Your Risk Tolerance

Home/Investing/Understanding Investing Risk and Your Risk Tolerance

Understanding investment risk and your personal risk tolerance is key to successful investing. Today we’ll visit both of those items to help you make intelligent investment decisions that are best for you.

Investing for beginners: Investment Risk

Investing Risk

The risk factors of investing are very often misunderstood.

Consider this situation to highlight how most people think of risk: Warren Buffett’s net worth dropped over $20 billion dollars through the Great Recession.

Question: How much money did Warren Buffett lose during the Great Recession?

Answer: He didn’t lose any money because he didn’t sell. Today his net worth is much higher than it was before the start of the Great Recession.

Market Swings: Volatility

What many people consider the biggest risk of investing is actually volatility. Volatility is when markets move – up or down. And that happens all the time. A market correction is defined by the value of the stocks as a whole drop 10% or more from a recent peak. This happens every 3-5 years on average. It’s a normal occurence that anyone interested in investing should understand.

If you have a long investing timeline – say 20 years or more – you shouldn’t care about volatility. Actually, that’s not quite right. You should care. You should care because if you are investing consistently, every time market prices drop you get to buy your shares at a discount!

Market Risk

On the other hand, if your investing timeline is shorter, then market volatility does turn into a risk factor.

The average market correction lasts less than two years. A couple of corrections in the past have lasted longer though. That’s the danger of just considering averages. If you are retiring within a couple of years and the market drops by 30%, it could impact your retirement goal. That’s why most financial advisors recommend clients consider shifting some money into less-volatile bonds as they get closer to retirement.


RELATED POST:
How To Invest When You Know Nothing About Investing


Purchasing Power Risk

Perhaps the second most important risk factor to consider, yet often ignored, is purchasing power risk. This is more commonly just referred to as inflation.

The United States has seen historic inflation rates average between 2 and 3% annually. That means that every year – on average – prices increase by 2-3%. If you are not investing, but instead have your money in a bank savings account, you are effectively losing money.

Because of inflation, your $1,000 today might only purchase $750 worth of goods in the future. Along the same lines, a household budget of $50,000 today might cost $75,000 by the time you retire. That needs to be considered in your investment planning. Ignoring this risk can derail your big financial goals.

Your Risk Tolerance

There are a number of factors to consider when thinking about your own investing risk tolerance. A good place to start is to ask yourself some questions. Vanguard has a questionnaire with some great thought-provoking questions – I’ll quote a couple of them here:

“From September 2008 through November 2008, stocks lost over 31%. If I owned a stock investment that lost about 31% in 3 months, I would: (If you owned stocks during this period, select the answer that corresponds to your actual behavior.)”

And a similar question of…

“From September 2008 through October 2008, bonds lost nearly 4%. If I owned a bond investment that lost almost 4% in 2 months, I would:(If you owned bonds during this period, select the answer that corresponds to your actual behavior.)”

The answers include sell everything, sell some of the investments, do nothing, or buy more. Selling – unless you had a critical need for the money – would of course be a low-tolerance answer. The “best” answer would be to do nothing – stick with the plan unless you actually need the money right away.


RELATED POST:
Addressing the #1 concern people have about investing


Balancing Risk With Your Risk Tolerance

Here’s an interesting chart I found over on the Fidelity site.

Risk and Return Over Time

As you can see – and so many financial experts like to say – “the market” has returned right around 10% per year on average. Of course “the market” means 100% stocks, so the returns have also been the most volatile short term.

Look at the 25% bond portfolio mix though. It has returned almost 9% per year annually – just 1.13% less per year than a total stock portfolio. Yet in exchange for that approximate 1% difference, worst year loss improves 22%!

Now look at the 40% bond portfolio mix. In that scenario you would sacrifice 2.09% annually on returns but improve upon the worst year performance by 40%.

Of course watching your portfolio balance drop by 40.64% can create some emotional turmoil. But it’s a lot better than watching it drop an additional 27%!

What Risk Level Can You Afford?

A CFP friend recently told me that there were three things to consider with risk tolerance.

1. What risk can you withstand. That’s similar to the questions that Vanguard asks in their questionnaire. Can you stay strong when things look rough?

2. What risk do you need to withstand. This comes down to what level of returns you need to meet your goals. You might want ultra-conservative investments but need a higher return than it provides. This factor definitely needs to be considered. Missing your goal because you wanted to minimize risk is a serious situation.

3. What risk do you want to withstand. I hadn’t considered this before. My wife and I are fairly risk tolerant. But we also don’t need to take a lot of risk to achieve our goals. So it comes down to what level of risk we want to take on. More risk means we’ll likely have more money later. Less risk means we’ll have less money – but still enough to achieve our goals. Interesting to consider for sure.


RELATED POST:
6 Things to Take Care of Before You Start Investing


Adjusted Rates Of Return

Because of inflation as noted above, you need to knock at least 2% off annual returns when financial planning. A 10% returns actually looks more like 8% after inflation.

Take a look at the chart above again.

Can you achieve your financial goals with an inflation-adjusted return of 5.93%? If so, then a 60/40 stock/bond mix portfolio might be perfect for you. If you need a higher return than that, then you’ll need to consider a higher volatility portfolio.

Of course because long timelines tend to lower risk, many people start out with very aggressive portfolios – sometimes 100% stocks. This gives the best returns on the investments over a long period of time. Once the investor gets closer to the time that they’ll need to access the money, they often shift into a more conservative mix. At that point they sacrifice potential returns, but lower their volatility. As long as someone doesn’t shift too conservative too early, this can often work out perfectly to achieve investment goals.

How About You?

What risk level can you stand? High, average, or low? What risk level do you need to achieve your goals? High, average, or low? What risk level would you prefer if the choice was wide open to you?

Let us know your thoughts in the comments section below.

 

Do you have a personal financial plan?

Financial planning checklist 2018 small

Here's a free personal financial planning checklist - to make sure you have the most important financial items covered.

Get it now and start checking points off the list.

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by ConvertKit

8 Comments

  1. Laura September 7, 2017 at 7:51 pm - Reply

    Great post! Knowing your risk tolerance and being able to sit still (or take advantage) of a recession is hard. Done it a couple times and it is uncomfortable. But as you said, it is also a chance to get some funds “on sale” as well as rebalance if your tolerance/allocation was out of whack.

  2. Gary @ Super Saving Tips September 7, 2017 at 8:47 pm - Reply

    That Fidelity chart is pretty interesting! Because I’m retired and my opportunities for additional income are limited, my risk tolerance is fairly low. I’m not naturally a risk taker anyway. However, my wife’s risk tolerance is higher because she is still 20 years away from retirement.

    • Brad Kingsley September 7, 2017 at 9:21 pm - Reply

      I thought so too Gary. Now that we’re retired there are more thoughts about risk – specifically sequence of returns risk. Thanks for stopping by!

  3. Jason@WinningPersonalFinance September 8, 2017 at 1:26 am - Reply

    I find these risk tolerance questions fascinating in that many people end up choosing an allocation that’s not mathematically ideal for their circumstances. My plan to stick with my planned asset allocation is to try and ignore the daily market movements as much as possible.

    • Brad Kingsley September 8, 2017 at 9:43 am - Reply

      Thanks for stopping by Jason! Yeah, it’s a tricky balance between the needed returns and acceptable levels of risk. Ignoring market moves is a GREAT idea for someone with a long investing timeline.

  4. Chintan @ Alpha Trading September 8, 2017 at 9:15 am - Reply

    Nice detailed article on Risk and Risk Tolerance.

Leave A Comment